GRADE 5 · ERROR ANALYSIS

Spot the Mistake: Multi-Digit Multiplication

Four students worked out the same problem. Only one got it right. Find the correct solution, then find the one mistake in each of the other three.

No timers. No penalties. Just careful checking.

Level: Cases solved: 0

CASE 1

  1. 1 · Find the correct oneCorrect one
  2. 2 · Find the mistakesMistakes
  3. 3 · ExplainExplain

How to Check a Multi-Digit Multiplication

  1. Check the first partial product

    Multiply the top number by the ones digit of the bottom number. In 528 × 17, that is 528 × 7 = 3,696.

  2. Check the second partial product

    Multiply by the tens digit. The 1 in 17 means 1 ten, so this line is 528 × 10 = 5,280. It always ends in 0.

  3. Check the sum

    Add the two partial products: 3,696 + 5,280 = 8,976.

  4. Estimate

    528 × 17 is about 500 × 20 = 10,000. An answer like 4,224 is far too small, which is a clue something went wrong.

Four Common Mistakes

MistakeWhat it looks like in 528 × 17
Multiplication fact slipOne fact is wrong, so a partial product is off: 528 × 7 written as 3,703 because 8 × 7 was taken as 63 instead of 56.
Missing zeroThe tens line is written as 528 instead of 5,280, so the answer comes out far too small.
Addition slipBoth partial products are right, but 3,696 + 5,280 is added as 8,876.
Forgotten carryA carried digit is not added inside a partial product, such as 3,646 instead of 3,696 (the 5 from 8 × 7 = 56 was never added to the tens).

Notice that after a mistake, the rest of the work can still be done correctly. A card with a missing zero adds its two lines perfectly. The mistake is earlier, so check every line, not just the answer.

For Parents and Teachers

This activity supports 5.NBT.B.5 (fluently multiply multi-digit whole numbers using the standard algorithm). The Long Multiplication Tutor teaches how to do the algorithm. This page practices the next skill: reading someone else's work and finding exactly where it went wrong.

Every case is generated fresh and checked: one card is fully correct, and each of the other three has exactly one mistake of a different kind. Every step after a mistake is worked correctly, so students can find the one wrong line by checking each step in turn.

Use Big screen to show one case to the whole class as a warm-up, then let partners compare their reasons. Need paper copies? The worksheet generator makes printable PDFs with a different set of cases for each student and answer keys.

FAQ

What grade is this for?

It is written for 5th grade multi-digit multiplication. Level 1 (2-digit × 2-digit) also works for 4th grade.

Why is finding mistakes useful?

Checking each line of someone else's work builds the same habits students need to check their own: knowing what each partial product means and estimating whether an answer makes sense.

Is there a time limit or a score?

No. There are no timers and no penalties. The counter only shows how many cases have been solved.

Can I use it on a Chromebook or a classroom screen?

Yes. It runs in any browser with no sign-up, and the Big screen button makes the numbers large enough for a projector.

Continue Learning

Learn the algorithm, then check it like a teacher.